Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Lillia Gajewski's avatar

So many words are misused in this country by media and academia, but until I read this essay I didn't understand completely why the use of "assimilation" bothered me. Now I know. Thank you for the enlightenment.

The real problem for the "left" these days is that much of what they define as "white supremacist values" are in fact just an old fashioned, nearly universal set of values that most cultures have shared from time immemorial (devotion to family, to some faith, to the community, to having a purpose and making yourself a useful member of society, generally through work of some kind). Those values are expressed in innumerable ways with variations in outcomes and priorities (god over family, family over god, community first or last, reasons for working hard and being ambitious, meaning are we honoring our family, trying to improve our circumstances, or serving our nation/community), but the foundations are all the same, and it's those foundations that they are intentionally or unintentionally eroding through this recoding and twisting of ideals and words.

Expand full comment
Apple Pie's avatar

Such a good essay. I love seeing things that I could never do; this is an essay that I could never write. Yet at the same time, it leaves me with a vague dissatisfaction - what are we all doing?

Yes, the left thinks America is bad, but the Democratic coalition really *is* America. It controls the national discourse, and relegates everybody who will not genuflect towards its sacred symbols into the conservative ghetto. Yet what good does it do to point this out? Your essay is brilliant, and instead of being a rallying point for sane people everywhere, it has 22 likes and 15 comments on substack. Shouldn't we have something better to do than put on YouTube music and browse through the latest documentation of the flaming nosedive that is the trajectory of American culture? Is this what all the Romans did in the 4th century - stand around and shake their heads at how weird everyone around them had become?

What about our kids? What are they supposed to *do* anyway? College connected me with the intelligent and hardworking woman who would someday be my wife, and gave me access to numerous career paths. But my kids can't meet smart, upwardly mobile people at college anymore, and the degrees are increasingly meaningless. I tell them to persevere in school and hold their nose against the propaganda, because there's something at the end; I tell them that liberal values like tolerance and creativity truly are worth something, because they help to build strong and innovative societies; but where does it all lead, and where will they end up?

What are we all doing anymore?

Expand full comment
17 more comments...

No posts